The assumptions we bring.

Photo by artawkrn on Unsplash

Our patient needed to be changed. He was secured in a wheelchair, and liquid stool was dripping onto the floor. I heard the patient’s nursing assistant chatting nearby and took that to mean she had a moment to help. I had time-sensitive medications to give, safety checks to perform, and assessments to complete. Those responsibilities could not be delegated. I stepped out of the patient’s room and asked her to clean him up. She was visibly upset by my request.

I spent much of the remainder of the shift resenting what I thought she believed about me: that I considered myself above cleaning a patient. She had not said so in those words, but that was the impression her response left with me. One request had made us so upset that we avoided each other for the rest of the shift.

I no longer remember whether I helped her or continued with my necessary nursing tasks. I do remember how quickly I became upset. I regularly washed my patients, cleaned up stool and urine, and did the unpleasant work that comes with caring for people. I thought she had taken my request to mean I didn’t want to do this particular task because it was dirty. I resented what felt like an accusation that I considered the work beneath me.

Delegation and interpretation.

The hierarchy between nurses and nursing assistants can complicate even ordinary interactions. A nurse may be balancing medications and other responsibilities that cannot be delegated, while a nursing assistant may be managing competing requests from several nurses. Neither may fully appreciate what the other is trying to manage. A request can feel like an attempt to pass off unpleasant work, while a question or hesitation can be interpreted as resistance or disrespect.

That day, I heard a conversation and assumed availability. When she reacted, I assumed I knew what she thought of me.

I know I can be an acquired taste. Different personalities and communication styles complicate working relationships even when people care about their work. I knew I was too hurt to have a useful conversation right away. When I speak from reflex, I am more likely to defend myself than to listen. I waited until later in the shift, when I thought we had both had time to cool down, and approached her privately.

The conversation.

The conversation was uncomfortable. I explained the tasks I was responsible for, and why I had asked for help. She told me she thought it was highly inappropriate to leave the patient in such a compromising position when I could have washed him myself. She believed I had been neglectful of our patient.

I had been so caught up in what I thought her anger said about me that I had not understood the seriousness of her concern. She was thinking about the patient’s immediate needs and dignity. I was thinking about the clinical responsibilities I was trying to balance.

We each understood something we had not understood during the exchange. We both cared about the patient and respected each other’s work ethic, even though we disagreed about what I should have done in that moment.

We both cried. We hugged. Our working relationship was stronger for it.

What we owe one another.

I could have finished that shift believing she was unfairly judging me. She could have finished it believing I had neglected our patient. We might have continued working together without ever questioning either interpretation. Instead, we gave each other the opportunity to explain, to listen, and to discover that our assumptions had obscured something important: we both cared.

I believe that one of the greatest acts of respect we can offer someone is the willingness to address a disagreement directly. It takes vulnerability to tell someone that something they did hurt or upset us, and humility to acknowledge that we may have misunderstood. Having that conversation gives both people the opportunity to explain themselves. It says that the relationship matters enough to try.

Our conversation ended well, but not every strained relationship can be repaired in one exchange. The authority to delegate does not mean our decisions are beyond question. Understanding someone’s intentions does not require agreeing with their decisions.

We talk often about whether a task was delegated appropriately. I think we also need to talk about the relationships in which delegation happens. Hierarchy, competing responsibilities, and the pressures of patient care can make it difficult to see beyond our own perspectives. Yet the people we work alongside may care just as deeply as we do, even when we disagree about what caring requires.

Courtney Desy, BSN, RN, OCN, is an oncology infusion nurse specializing in the care of adults receiving chemotherapy and immunotherapy. She is the founder of the Stronger Than Chemo Foundation, a nonprofit dedicated to improving patient education and support during cancer treatment. Her last post on this blog was “The Personalities of Veins: What Thousands of IV Starts Have Taught Me.”


Discover more from Off the Charts

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.