When I was an ED nurse in a city hospital years ago, we often received patient transfers from area nursing homes. Usually these patients were very elderly, appeared cachectic, and were largely unresponsive (as I recall, many were post-stroke or had dementia). Diagnoses were usually very similar: dehydration, hypotension, UTI, pneumonia; many had contractures. The usual care was rehydration with IV fluids, an NG tube, antibiotics, and often a Foley catheter. Sometimes they were septic and then they were intubated, placed on ventilators, and sent to the ICU, where just about everyone died after a short stay.

What’s the point of this care?

I often wondered, as did many of my colleagues, what was the point of this. It seemed futile, and injurious to the patient. Sometimes, if we could reach family members before nasogastric or endotracheal tubes were placed, we were able to secure an order to dispense with all but comfort measures. Otherwise, all measures were initiated and then things became complicated—legal issues arose about discontinuing futile care and families often couldn’t bring themselves to discontinue life support measures.

Today, a greater focus on advance care planning.

Advance care planning (ACP) was hit or miss in those days—mostly miss—and our patients suffered because of this. It’s only recently that emphasis has been placed […]